DIY Logo Design vs. Hiring a Professional

1/29/2025

Logos are an essential part of a brand. They represent what a business stands for and help people remember it. When someone sees your logo on a product or a website, they should connect it with the identity of your company. Over the years, I’ve worked with many business owners who were torn between creating a logo themselves or getting help from a professional designer. Both choices can lead to unique outcomes, but they also bring challenges.

In this article, we will explore the differences between DIY Logo Design vs. Hiring a Professional. We will go through the advantages, downsides, and special factors to consider before you make your decision. I will share personal experiences from my time at Kickass Designs in Portland, Oregon, where I’ve been designing logos and providing branding solutions since 2010. My goal is to help you understand the best approach for your own brand, without using complicated jargon or false promises.

By the end, you should have a clear idea of what it takes to create a logo that works well for your business. We will also go over some frequently asked questions, so you can see different scenarios where DIY might work and where professional help is key.

The Importance of a Good Logo

A logo is more than just a symbol. It’s often the first point of contact between a brand and its audience. Over the years, I’ve seen how a memorable logo can help a business stand out in a crowded market. On the other hand, a forgettable or poor-quality design can make even great companies appear unprofessional.
For a deeper look into why a strong logo matters, check out our post:

7 Reasons Why a Logo is Important to Your Brand

Here are a few reasons a good logo can help:

Brand Recognition: A simple and clear design will be easier for people to remember.
Professional Appearance: A polished look helps new customers trust your brand from the start.
Consistency: Using the same logo across all channels—website, social media, signage—makes your brand feel more cohesive.

If you want to learn more about the fundamentals, you can also visit our blog on the Principles of Effective Logos. These guidelines cover elements like balance, scalability, and color choices, which help you gauge a logo’s effectiveness.

DIY Logo Design: What Does It Involve?

DIY logo design means you create your own logo without hiring a professional. You can sketch it out, then use digital tools like Adobe Illustrator, Canva, or other free online platforms to finalize it. Some people also experiment with AI-based generators. While these tools are getting more sophisticated, they can be limiting if you want a truly unique design.

Pros of DIY:

Cost Control
You often pay nothing beyond the tool or software subscription you might already have. This seems like an obvious advantage if your budget is tight.
Creative Freedom
If you have a clear idea of what you want, you can skip back-and-forth communication and work at your own pace. You don’t have to explain your vision to another person.
Learning Experience
For those who enjoy learning new skills, creating a logo can be a rewarding process. You might learn about typography, color theory, and design principles along the way.

Cons of DIY:

Time Commitment
Designing a logo requires research, brainstorming, and revisions. If you’re not a full-time designer, you might find this process very time-consuming.
Limited Tools and Skills
While free tools can be great, they may not offer advanced features for truly custom designs. Also, without a background in design, you might miss out on methods professionals use.
Inconsistent Results
A DIY design can look good when you first create it, but might not scale well across different mediums. You might end up with a logo that looks stretched or blurred on some platforms.
Risk of Generic Look
Many DIY logo tools offer templates. Even if you change colors and fonts, you risk ending up with a design that looks like many others. Standing out can become difficult.

I often see clients who tried a DIY approach realize later that their logo doesn’t fit all their branding needs. This leads them to seek professional help, and in the process, they end up investing more money and time than if they had hired a professional from the start. That said, DIY can still be useful for small projects or hobby businesses that aren’t aiming for rapid growth.

For a look at potential issues that can happen if you rely too much on automated tools, read our article on The Hidden Pitfalls of AI Logo Design: Your Brand Deserves Better.

Hiring a Professional Logo Designer

Hiring a professional involves paying someone with specialized skills and experience to create your logo. Many of our clients at Kickass Designs in Portland, Oregon, come to us because they need custom work that properly reflects their brand identity. My team and I have been designing since 2010, and we’ve handled projects for small startups as well as Fortune 500 companies.

How the Process Usually Works

Consultation
We start by understanding your business, audience, and goals. This helps us get a feel for what your brand needs to communicate.
Design Brief
We’ll ask you specific questions about the mood and style you have in mind. We also look at any inspirations you’ve collected.
Concept Development
We create initial sketches and digital mockups. Then we refine the best ideas into complete logo concepts.
Revisions
We work with you on tweaks and refinements. Sometimes it’s a small color change or a font adjustment.
Finalization
When you’re satisfied, we deliver the final logo in different file formats for both web and print.

Pros of Hiring a Professional

Expertise
Professional designers have training and hands-on experience. They know about design theory, color psychology, and how to make a logo that scales well.
Time Savings
Instead of spending days or weeks trying to make it perfect, you can focus on other parts of your business while a designer handles the logo.
Unique, Custom Work
Professionals create designs that stand out. We don’t rely on templates or clip art. Every element is custom-made for your brand.
Long-Term Value
A well-designed logo can serve your brand for years, giving you a return on investment that often outweighs the upfront cost.
Consistency Across Platforms
Designers ensure that your logo will work on everything from business cards to large billboards. You won’t have scaling or resolution issues.

At Kickass Designs, we offer Unlimited Revisions, a Satisfaction Guarantee, and files ready for both print and web. The entire process typically takes a few days for initial concepts and about 24 hours for each revision stage. We understand that building a brand can be stressful, so we keep our process simple.

Cons of Hiring a Professional

Cost
Professional design fees can be higher than using a free online tool. However, the overall value can justify the price.
Communication
You need to clearly explain your vision. While professionals are good at interpreting needs, misunderstandings can happen if communication is unclear.
Time for Back-and-Forth
Even though you save time by not designing it yourself, you still need to approve concepts and give feedback. The process can take longer than expected if there are many revisions.

Personal Perspective: Balancing Creativity and Business Goals

I’m Lance Reis, the owner of Kickass Designs in Portland, Oregon. I started this business to help people who feel overwhelmed by the idea of branding. When I first began, I noticed many clients had tried creating their own logos. Some of them did decent work with limited resources. But as their businesses grew, they realized they needed something more polished and scalable.

One memorable case was a local bakery that had created a pretty good DIY logo. It worked fine on their website, but when they wanted to print it on large banners for a food festival, they saw it became pixelated. They reached out to us to refine it. By the time we finished, they not only had a logo that scaled up nicely, but also a set of consistent branding elements for packaging, social media, and staff uniforms.

It’s these situations that remind me how important it is to think about the long-term implications of a logo design. Even if you’re just starting out, you might grow faster than you expect. A quick DIY project can hold you back later if it doesn’t align with professional standards.

Understanding Color Psychology and Other Design Aspects

A logo isn’t just about a shape or a font. Color choice also plays a major role in how people perceive your brand. For instance, red often signals passion or urgency, while blue feels calm and trustworthy. These are general impressions, but they can make a difference in how your audience responds.

To learn more about choosing the right colors for your design, read our blog on Color Psychology in Logo Design & Branding. Here are a few key points:

Contrast: Helps important parts of the logo stand out.
Color Combinations: Certain pairings can communicate very different moods.
Target Audience: Consider age, gender, and culture when picking a color scheme.

Professionals often conduct research into your industry’s color trends and your competitors’ color palettes to make sure your logo doesn’t blend in too much or clash in the wrong way.

When Should You Update an Existing Logo?

Sometimes, the question isn’t whether to go DIY or professional for a new logo, but whether you should update an existing one. Logos can become outdated due to design trends, technology changes, or shifts in a company’s products or services. If you want to explore reasons for a refresh, see our post on 4 Reasons to Update Your Logo. You might consider a logo update if:

Your company has changed direction.
You’ve expanded your product lines.
You want to stay current with modern design trends.
Your logo looks pixelated or unclear in certain formats.

Even if you already have a logo, working with a professional for an update can ensure consistency. They can refine existing elements to make the design better without losing brand recognition.

Brand Consistency and Personal Branding

A logo is one piece of the larger branding puzzle. Personal branding is especially critical for freelancers, consultants, or anyone building a name for themselves. If you’re aiming to create a consistent personal brand that includes your face, name, or signature, the logo should match that style.

For a deeper dive into personal branding, check out 5 Personal Branding Tips for Small Business. In general:

Keep your voice and imagery consistent across your website, social media, and physical materials.
Use the same color palette in your logo, social media banners, and business cards.
Make sure any photographs or icons reflect the same mood as your brand’s overall theme.

Whether you go DIY or hire someone, consistent branding can help people recognize and trust you.

Trends vs. Timeless Design

Design trends change. A style that looked fresh a few years ago might seem dated today. Minimalist logos, for example, have been popular for a while and might remain relevant for the near future because they are easy to recognize and use across different media. But some trends last only a short time, and blindly following them can cause a logo to become outdated quickly.

Here are two resources for further reading:

If you decide to handle your logo design yourself, be careful about jumping on every trend. Focus on what fits your brand and will still make sense a few years from now.

Cost Comparisons and Return on Investment (ROI)

DIY: The main costs might be software subscriptions, stock images or fonts (if any), and your time. If the result isn’t strong, you risk paying for redesign later.

Professional: You pay upfront for design services, but you typically get a strong and scalable design that lasts. The ROI often comes in the form of brand recognition, customer trust, and less need for major updates.

In my experience, the difference in cost between a quick DIY solution and a professional design usually narrows over the life of a brand. Quality logos rarely need constant overhauls. And if you consider the value of your own time, paying a professional can actually be more cost-effective in the long run.

Finding the Right Professional

If you do decide to hire a professional, choose wisely. Some freelancers or agencies specialize in certain industries or design styles. It helps to look at portfolios and read client reviews. We’ve been fortunate at Kickass Designs to receive over 90 Five-star reviews, which reflect our approach of providing unique, custom designs without hidden fees.

If you’re in Portland or anywhere else, and want more tips on choosing the right designer, take a look at Choosing the Perfect Logo Designer in Portland: An Expert’s Guide. It outlines:

What questions to ask a designer before hiring them.
How to gauge their understanding of your brand.
The significance of deadlines and revision policies.

Making Your Decision

Assess Your Budget
If you have a very small budget, DIY might be the only option. But if you can allocate funds, professional design could be a wise investment.

Evaluate Your Timeline
If you’re launching a business in a short timeframe, a DIY approach might seem faster. But a professional designer with a quick turnaround policy can also deliver quality on schedule.

Consider Your Goals
If you want a unique identity that can grow with your business, a professional design is usually better. For a side project or a hobby, DIY might be good enough.

Check Your Skills
If you have a background in design or a knack for it, DIY could work well. Otherwise, you might waste time figuring out software and best practices.

Review the Long-Term Impact
A logo is a long-term representation of your brand. Changing it too often can confuse your audience. A professional logo can help maintain consistency from the start.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Can I try DIY first and then hire a designer later?

Yes. Some people start with a DIY logo to save money. As the business grows, they hire a professional for a more polished design. Keep in mind, though, that rebranding can be more expensive if you have already printed or published marketing materials with the old logo.

2. How much does a professional logo designer cost?

Costs vary depending on the designer’s experience, location, and complexity of the project. Freelancers might offer packages from a few hundred to a few thousand dollars, while agencies can charge significantly more. At Kickass Designs, we have packages for different budgets, starting from simple designs to full branding suites.

3. What if I don’t like the final design?

Many professionals, including us, offer revision rounds. At Kickass Designs, we provide Unlimited Revisions and a Satisfaction Guarantee. This means we will keep working on your logo until you’re happy with the final result.

4. How long does the professional design process take?

It depends on the designer’s workload and your availability to give feedback. Generally, we deliver first concepts in 2-3 days and handle each revision in about 24 hours. More complex designs or indecision on the client’s part can make the process longer.

5. Is it okay to use AI tools for parts of the design?

Some designers use AI-based tools to brainstorm ideas or assist with tasks like background removal. However, relying on AI for the entire process can lead to generic outcomes. If you’re considering AI for your entire logo, read our insights in The Hidden Pitfalls of AI Logo Design: Your Brand Deserves Better.

6. Should I update my logo or create a new one from scratch?

This depends on how much brand equity you have built with your current logo. If the logo is widely recognized, a refresh might be enough. If the design is causing confusion or no longer represents your brand, a complete overhaul may be better. Check out 4 Reasons to Update Your Logo for more details.

7. Will a minimalist logo always look too simple?

Minimalist logos focus on clarity and timelessness. They are designed with fewer elements to make them memorable. This doesn’t mean they lack character. It means every element serves a purpose. For more on this, see Minimalist Logos: The Key to Timeless and Modern Branding.

8. Do I need an entire branding package or just a logo?

This depends on your goals. A complete branding package includes color palettes, font families, and style guides. If you only need a symbol for your website or business cards, a single logo file might be enough. However, for long-term brand consistency, a broader package is helpful.

9. How do I choose the right colors if I design the logo myself?

Research your industry and consider color psychology. Look at brands you admire and see how they use color to create a certain mood. You can read about Color Psychology in Logo Design & Branding for detailed guidance.

10. How do I protect my logo legally?

Once you have a final design, consider registering it as a trademark. Rules differ by country, but in general, trademark registration can protect your design from unauthorized use. It’s best to consult a legal professional if you have concerns about intellectual property.

Conclusion

DIY Logo Design vs. Hiring a Professional is a choice many business owners face. A DIY approach might fit very tight budgets or personal projects, providing flexibility and control. However, it can also require significant time, skill, and potential rework. Hiring a professional, on the other hand, brings expertise and a polished end product, usually with a higher initial cost but better long-term benefits.

I’ve seen countless clients at Kickass Designs who tried to create their own logos and ended up requiring professional help later. I’ve also met a few who successfully designed their own logos because they had the skills or connections for feedback. The key is to align your decision with your budget, design ability, business goals, and future needs.

If you decide to hire a professional, look for someone who understands your brand, offers clear communication, and has a track record of delivering on time. If you decide to go the DIY route, do your research, study design principles, and keep it simple. Above all, think about the long-term influence a logo has on your brand. It’s not just an image; it’s the public face of your business.

Internal Resources for Further Reading:

If you have questions or want to talk about your own logo ideas, feel free to reach out. Remember: a logo should represent who you are and where you want to go as a business. Whether you do it yourself or work with a professional, make sure it reflects your vision in a way that resonates with your audience.

0 Comments